Will Manchester United beat Tottenham on Saturday?
/
Jamie "The Pacman" Pacheco /
27 October 2010 /
1 Comments
Former Spurs star Dimitar Berbatov can have a big impact on this match
It's the televised match on Saturday evening and the key fixture of another busy weekend of Premier League football. Jamie Pacheco and Gary Boswell tells us where they stand on the outcome....
Yes
By Gary Boswell
He chews them up and he spits them out! David Beckham, Cristiano Ronaldo and now Wayne Rooney. Except that Wayne is staying and if you bought all that media gumpf last week as an indication of Manchester United as a club in turmoil then more fool you.
We only get the bits they want to feed us and I personally remain solidly in the Sir Alex is boss camp. He sends them out this weekend and they do a job on Stoke that highlights the newest young thing on the block, Javier Hernandez. Business back to normal with the trademark late winner just as it looked like Stoke had nicked a point. Vintage United and very much orchestrated from the bench as far as I could see. All the signs are that Hernandez will ultimately be doing the Ferguson bidding in the months and years to come. If he’d wanted Rooney out (and he may well still do for Ferguson is canny business manager aswell as proven football boss), you wouldn’t have seen the boy for dust in my view. Much more likely that Sir Alex is trying various methods to get some form recovery. Get Rooney focussing back on his football.
I thought Edwin Van der Sar’s ‘Robert Green’ against Albion was more worrying. If that happens again you might start considering laying the odds at Old Trafford as a regular feature. Although I’ve thought about it after missing out when my Baggy boys visited, I don’t seriously expect that as the start of a trend.
Unlike Liverpool, I do not consider Manchester United’s slightly indifferent early season form to shape their season. Ferguson tinkers before Xmas every year before solidifying his mettle at the business end. No different this year. There are changes to his preferred starting eleven as always. New and younger players breaking through is his forte and there’s no shortage this year. He gives them time to bed down without it costing too much. I’d say it is working again. The young line up against Bursaspor weren’t spectacular but they won as they should. That is the Ferguson way.
You’ll see the big guns out against Spurs. They are going to have to take Gareth Bale very seriously after what he has been doing but Spurs’ defence is still highly broachable. A current form dip to boot with the points dropped at home to Everton.
For all their supposed troubles, United have scored eleven in four home league games and there is no question in my mind that they have the potency to undo the Spurs defence. Nemanja Vidic and Van der Sar do their job at the back (and granted that is more the issue with United having conceded an unexpected twelve in nine so far), the win is still there for the taking.
I expect a good game. Harry Redknapp will have no fears coming into this climate and he has got Spurs believing in their ability to score goals. The [6.2] win price is a degree of value if you think United are vulnerable but personally I don’t. I’m strongly predicting a home win. Nani, Dimitar Berbatov, Darren Fletcher – nevermind Hernandez - are good enough for me with or without Rooney now.
[1.66] is giving nothing away and I don’t consider this one of my value calls but I’ll take it nevertheless. A winner is a winner and I expect United to be that.
No
By Jamie Pacheco
First things first. For all the talk of Manchester United turning a corner and how their win over Stoke was symbolic of a new-found confidence and resilience, let’s not forget one not so minor detail – Gary Neville should have been sent off. I don’t like to see teams reduced to ten men any more than the next football fan but the rules are the rules. The early sending off of Dedryck Boyata a few hours later spoilt what was likely to be a cracking game of football, but it’s not a referee’s job to decide that a player’s rightful dismissal is outweighed by our loss of a good spectacle. We’ll never know what would have happened if Neville had been sent off of course, but we can safely say United’s job would have been much harder.
I’ve watched more of United this season than any other club and I’ve been far from impressed with what I’ve seen. A clanger from Edwin Van Der Sar against West Brom, two goal leads slipping both home and away and a goalless draw against Rangers (the banker in most people’s mid-week Multiple) were just some of the low points. There have been some positives: the early form of Dimitar Berbatov, the new found freedom and confidence of Nani and the precocious talent of Javier Hernandez. The negatives outweigh the positives though and irrespective of the boost that Wayne Rooney’s contract extension has given to dressing room and fans (and confirmation as if it were needed that Sir Alex still rules the roost at Old Trafford) I expect United’s struggles on the pitch to continue.
And that starts with Tottenham on Saturday. This is virtually the same side that finished fourth last season with the priceless addition of Rafael Van Der Vaart in the starting XI. The former Real Madrid man is a rare talent but one who needs to be nurtured if he is to succeed. If you’re going to have him at your club as a squad player or ask him to play in a regimented way you might as well not bother having him at all. He needs to feel loved, needs to start every match when fit and needs to be given total freedom to roam, just like Harry Redknapp has been doing. The “free role” isn’t in fashion these days and it’s a luxury few can afford but RVDV is good enough to warrant it and I’m confident he can hurt United on Saturday.
Then there’s Gareth Bale. I’ll hold fire with the over-the-top praise for the Welshman until he puts in first-rate performances over the course of a whole season but I’ll happily highlight the one asset he possesses that causes huge problems for any defender in the world: pace. Neither Gary Neville (try and pull that stunt two weeks in a row, Gaz) nor John O’Shea can live with his speed and Rafael lacks the experience to know whether to stick tight or sit back and let him come to you. Whoever is in charge of keeping him quiet has a job I wouldn’t want to do for the day. And it’s not often I say that about a Premier League footballer.
Sport News 24/7
Oyugi | 28 October 2010
Sir Alex Ferguson,I humbly plead with you to leave out Dimitar,Fletcher,Scholes in Tottenham crash.Play Wayne.We are already nursing several wounds as fans and we aren't willing to take anymore.Restore our faith in you!